Reviewing The Changes Of Government Policy social Work Essay

By charting alterations in authorities policy and public assistance political orientations, this essay will discourse the significance of the move from the Victorian pauper towards the twenty-first century service User and analyze how this has influenced societal work values and pattern. But first, brief consideration must be given to offering a definition of these footings. The Oxford English Dictionary ( 2009: online ) defines a pauper as person with no belongings or agencies of support ; who is dependent upon charity from others ; and a mendicant. Terminology has changed dramatically and the term service user emerged in the 1990s as the generic name for people societal workers work with ( Pierson Thomas, 2006: 560 ) . In contrast to pauper, the Collins Internet-Linked Dictionary of societal Work by Pierson and Thomas ( 2006: 560 ) provinces:

its popularity has spread among practicians, directors and societal work pedagogues likewise as it seems to convey the more modern-day accent on those who receive the service holding some rights and influence over that service

All societies have methods of helping those in fiscal troubles ( Payne, 2005: 13 ) and the 1601 English Poor Law was the first national public assistance proviso that lasted in one signifier or another for 350 old ages ( spicker, 2008: 78 ) . However, in the eighteenth century, the Poor Law Report demonstrated the current allowance system was corrupting and promoted idling ( Fraser, 2009: 53 ) . This, coupled with a proliferation of paupers and intensifying alleviation costs, led to the Poor Law Amendment Act 1834 which heralded the debut of workhouses, designed to discourage everyone but the destitute from using for support ( Thane, 1996: 31 ) . It was hoped by replacing out-of-door alleviation with the workhouse, the mistakes of the current system would be corrected ( Fraser, 2009: 55 ) . Ultimately, it provided a rough alternate to self-help that the pauper would merely accept when destitute ; and fearing the workhouse, they would hopefully happen employment ( Ibid. : 55-56 ) . This was in maintaining with the general societal doctrine of the clip that supposed work forces were Masterss of their ain destiny and that the person had within his appreciation the power to happen his ain redemption. Those necessitating aid were blamed for their place and expected to happen solutions to their ain self-imposed wretchedness ( Sullivan, 1996: fourteen ) . Therefore, the Victorian Poor Law divided the needy into the deserving and unworthy hapless ; with the meriting worthy of philanthropic aid whilst the undeserving was punished for their feckless behavior ( Ibid. ) . In kernel, the Amendment Act successfully forced able-bodied work forces to take duty for themselves ( Thane, 1996: 33 ) .

Throughout the 1880s charitable responses to enduring grew ( Payne, 2005: 36 ) and the Charitable Organisation society was established in 1869, taking to carry charities to organize resources so they were distributed to those best able to utilize them ( Thane, 1996: 21 ) . The COs was non an option to the Poor Law, but the impudent side of the same coin ( Payne, 2005: 36 ) and its rules encouraged people to go self-dependent and merely helped those with possible to back up themselves ( Thane, 1996: 21 ) . It provided charity for the deserving and hence, left those without possible to go self-dependent to destitution or the Poor Law. Furthermore, COs endeavoured to happen permanent solutions to peoples jobs, without taking them from their environment and pioneered the pattern of case-work whereby probes were conducted into clients backgrounds who were so helped if deemed worthy. Much had to be said for this case-work attack, which provided a existent effort to look into the nature of the peoples jobs and basically, through the development of this method, created societal work ( Payne, 2005: 38 ) .

Many people following COs rules in theory found it disputing to abandon those in despairing demand in pattern ( Thane, 1996: 23 ) . Hence, dissatisfaction generated new voluntary attacks, including the colony Movement, which initiated modern community work. Residential colony Toynbee Hall was established in 1884 where alumnuss would populate and work among the hapless ; a theoretical account replicated throughout the state by the terminal of the century. It aimed for them to use their moral illustration and instruction to further societal development ( Payne, 2005: 37 ) and its warden Samuel Barnett believed category harmoniousness and stuff betterment would merely better when the rich regarded the hapless as every bit worthy persons ( Thane, 1996: 21 ) .

Traveling to the 20th century, following the 2nd World War, cardinal public assistance alterations were introduced under the Labour authorities in conformity with a design proposed in the 1942 Beveridge Report ( Bochel, 2008: 192 ) . later, the period from 1945 until the 1970s is considered:

One of political consensus on cardinal issues, stemming from a combination of the economic doctrine of Keynes, and the societal policy of Beveridge, enshrining the thoughts of the assorted economic system and the public assistance province.

During this period it was assumed societies had progressed, rendering the province responsible for supplying cosmopolitan welfare proviso for citizens ( Payne, 2005: 50 ) . later, the province established a scope of societal services in the new epoch of public assistance capitalist economy and this societal security was regarded as the instrument that would eliminate poorness ( Sullivan, 1996: xiii-3 ) . The public assistance province was created to set public assistance on a new terms ( Briggs, 1961 cited in spicker, 2008: 121 ) where everyone, non merely the hapless, had the right to entree services ( spicker, 2008: 121 ) . This contrasted starkly to when support was confined to the destitute and intentionally made unpleasant under the Poor Law ( Checkland Checkland, 1974 cited in spicker, 2008: 121 ) and this committedness to universalism provided an obvious alteration from the yesteryear ( Sullivan, 1996: 54 ) . Furthermore, societal work was going accepted as portion of cosmopolitan public assistance proviso alongside wellness, lodging and societal security ( Payne, 2005: 50 ) and in the 25 old ages following the war, a gradual professionalizing displacement occurred ( Lymberry, 2001: 371 ) . later, following the 1968 seebohm Report and the 1970 Local Authority societal services Act, the three bing personal societal services were reorganised into incorporate local authorization sections ( Sullivan, 1996: 195-196 ) . It was hoped this would supply a more coordinated and comprehensive attack to the jobs of persons, households and communitiesA? ( seebohm Report, 1968 quoted in Lymberry, 2001: 371 ) . Basically, this was a period of proliferation and consolidation for societal work with the hope it would lend towards making a more equal society ( Lymberry, 2001: 371 ) .

This motion to the public assistance province from the Poor Law is referred to as the patterned advance to E?institutional public assistance from E?residual proviso ( Wilensky Lebeaux, 1965 cited in spicker, 2008: 92 ) . Residual public assistance catered for a limited figure of people, was provided under sufferance and regarded as a public load ( spicker, 2008: 92 ) . Furthermore, the Poor Law was punitory in nature, limited liabilities through disincentive and disadvantaged paupers of their rights. Contrastingly, institutional public assistance covered the general populations demands, irrespective of their fiscal fortunes, and offered protection to everyone. It was built on accepting common duty, considered dependence to be normal, and was based on the premiss of a right to welfare and citizenship. Theoretically, this universalism provided the lone manner to vouch high quality of services were available for all and removed the stigma associated with province services ( Sullivan, 1996: 54 ) .

During the two decennaries after the war, authoritiess believed in Keynesian demand direction techniques and Beveridges societal thoughts ( Ibid. : 90 ) . However, from the late 1960s these economic policies failed and the UK faced a financial crisis of the province ( Ibid. ) . later, when the Conservatives were elected in 1979, the political orientation of the New Right dominated and heralded a alteration from the post-war public assistance consensus ( Lymberry, 2001: 372 ) . This period was characterised by Neo-liberal thought, which basically questioned the state-delivered establishments organizing the public assistance province, and these beliefs have affected policy-making and the public assistance system during recent decennaries ( Ellison, 2008: 61-67 ) . For illustration, Thatchers authorities was dedicated to turn overing back the province and denying common committednesss among citizens because allegedly society did non be but comprised of viing persons alternatively ( Lowe, 1999: 307 ) . They aspired for those dependent on the province to go independent because:

If those in demand were encouraged to look passively to the province for aid, they would be denied the inspiring experience of self-help and of household or community attention.

Therefore, the New Right were committed to re-moralising society, merely as Poor Law reformists of the 1830s had before them, with a return to Victorian values. This generated a decrease in benefits and conditions stipulated for accessing these were toughened ( Clarke et al. , 2000: 3 ) . Furthermore, an increasing stigma was attached to publically provided public assistance and it was, in some respects, criminalised by associating Us impressions of public assistance dependence anddemoralisation to UK thoughts of foraging and undeserving. Basically, public assistance had come full circle when:

Individuality as the motor of economic and societal policy in the nineteenth and early twentieth centurys gave manner to the Bolshevism of that authoritative public assistance province merely to re-emerge in the late twentieth centuryA? ( Sullivan, 1996: fifteen ) .

New Right accent on the holiness of matrimony and household, the demonisation of those who threatened these and their publicity of a societal order based on Victorian values impacted on societal work ( Lymberry, 2001: 372 ) . It was forced to abandon its pretenses to supplying a universalist service and concentrate on statutory responsibilities, excluding the preventive remit laid out in the seebohm Report. Furthermore, it underlined persons looking after themselves and their households ( Bochel, 2008: 194 ) . later, societal work changed after the Barclay Report of the 1980s, which introduced community societal work schemes and encouraged local authorization societal services sections to develop alternate ways of run intoing societal demand ( sullivan, 1996: 196 ) . This attack envisaged traveling from the traditional one-to-one focal point towards easing self-help by communities, societal webs, and persons. Furthermore, it heralded the motion of societal workers from healers to enablers, back uping informal carers alternatively of supplying the attention themselves ( Ibid. ) .

When looking at New Labour and their E?Third Way attack, a decisive displacement has occurred in the function of the receivers of societal work services. For illustration, Blair ( 2000 cited in Jordan, 2001: 529 ) intended to alter the public assistance province from presenting inactive support towards active support, advancing citizens independency alternatively. Taking the in-between land between free-market rules of the Conservative old ages and old manner socialism it meant services would demand more from citizens, necessitating people to lend to a responsible community ( Jordan, 2001: 529-530 ) . This tougher attack to public assistance is apparent in anticipating many individual parents, the handicapped, and those having employment benefits to actively seek employment ( Ellison, 2008: 67 ) . Additionally, benefits are now less generous and more purely means-tested than in the tallness of Keynesian public assistance.

Furthermore, the development of anti-oppressive pattern signals a alteration in the attitudes towards the function of users of societal work services. Anti-oppressive pattern has emerged over the last decennary, signifiers portion of the critical societal work tradition, and is concerned with transforming power dealingss at every degree in pattern ( Healy, 2005: 172-178 ) . Theorists believe the societal work function is political with societal workers keeping a privileged position in comparing to service users. Therefore, societal workers must be critical and brooding in order to non retroflex oppressive societal dealingss in pattern. Furthermore, it promotes working in partnership with service users with power truly shared at both an interpersonal and institutional degree ( Dalrymple and Burke, 1995: 65 cited in Healy, 2005: 187 ) . Thus, service users chances for engagement in decision-making should be maximised ( Healy, 2005: 187 ) .

societal work has been affected by the unabated promotion of consumer capitalist economy and service users are expected to be more involved in set uping and pull offing services ( Harris, 2009: 67 ) . The New Right thoughts emphasised that citizens had a right to freedom and pick and recent Conservative and Labour disposals have encouraged citizens to take part in public assistance services ; using market-like attacks to audience and increased authorization in decision-making ( Bochel, 2008: 194 ) . Attempts have been made to advance service user engagement in planning and development with the position that their active function improves wellness and societal attention services ( Carr, 2004: 2 ) . Furthermore, the importance of single pick in bettering supplier effectivity, the impression of citizens rights and duties and a belief that persons involvement in decision-making consequences in solutions that better run into their demands have been underlined ( Bochel, 2008: 194-195 ) . This is apparent in the Direct Payments strategy, endorsed on the footing of pick and independency, and demonstrates that the province progressively expects citizens to be competent enterprising, managerial and independent persons ( scourfield, 2007: 108 ) . However, as scourfield ( Ibid. ) asserts this raises concerns about dependent citizens and accents:

a danger of utilizing independency and pick as cardinal forming rules is to bury how and why the populace sector emerged in the first topographic point ” to guarantee that those who are needfully dependent are treated with regard and self-respect, to guarantee a collectivised attack to put on the line, and to guarantee that secure and dependable signifiers of support outside of the market or the household are availableA? .

Additionally, as Carr ( 2004: 2 ) found, the extent to which service user engagement leads to betterments in services varies and there is small monitoring and rating of the difference user engagement is doing. Furthermore, despite citizenship, pick, community, societal inclusion and liberty being cardinal to New Labours programme, ( Blair, 1998 cited in Humphries, 2004: 95 ) Humphries ( 2004: 95 ) contends Labours pursuing of neo-liberal economic and morally inhibitory policies has degraded public services ; penalizing and excepting those regarded as holding been E?given a opportunity but holding E?failedA? . she proposes it is societal workers who are expected to implement the surveillance systems that operate these policies and under New Labour a displacement has occurred towards societal work holding an progressively negative and narrow pattern focussed on limitation, surveillance, control and exclusion. Therefore, societal work is concerned with the moralistic side of Labours policies instead than with authorising people alternatively ( Jordan, 2001 cited in Humphries, 2004: 94 ) . Furthermore, since 1993, progressively punitory and inhibitory steps have been introduced to discourage refuge searchers from coming to Britain and if they are granted entree they enter an inhumane and inferior public assistance system ( Humphries, 2004: 100 ) . Acts such as the 1993 Asylum and Immigration Appeals Act and the 1996 Asylum and Immigration Act removed those capable to in-migration controls from the public assistance province and Cohen ( 2003 cited in Humphries, 2004: 101 ) describes the refuge support system as the creative activity of a modern twenty-four hours hapless jurisprudence based on coercion and deficiency of pick.

This essay has documented the move from the usage of the Victorian term pauper to the twenty-first century term service user by looking at displacements in authorities policy and public assistance political orientations and its impact on societal work. Looking back, one would trust we have progressed from the Victorian Poor Law that blamed the pauper for their demand of aid and deterred them from accessing support by rendering it every bit unpleasant as possible. However, when detecting the rigorous means-tested benefit system and New Labours tough attack public assistance, determining whether we have moved frontward becomes questionable. Zarb ( 2006: 2 ) , mentioning to how older twosomes can be separated due to lodging and attention allotment, inquiries whether citizens are still treated like the paupers in the Poor Law epoch who were on a regular basis split up for non run intoing the parishes criteria for support. Furthermore, to complete, Wynne-Jones ( 2007: online ) , composing on the Joseph Rowntree Foundation web site, high spots that today the media still assigns different types of morality to types of poorness:

The ‘undeserving hapless ‘ are the Asbo childs and the hoodies, the dependent and long-run unemployed. On the other manus, thedeserving hapless look a batch like in-between Englanders fallen on difficult timesA? .

Having spent clip with a group of troubled immature people on a Peckham estate, following the decease of Damilola Taylor in 2000, she believes that it is through the stereotypic comedy characters such as Little Britains vicky Pollard that Middle England reveals how threatened it feels about the unworthy hapless ; using comedy as a agency of knocking our societies lower class. she maintains that as Middle England laughs from the malaise that people like this exist on our poorest estates, old ages on from Damilolas decease, we are still neglecting those, like the group in Peckham, who are damaged so severely by life that their lone authorization is to assail others. Therefore, to reason, whilst a alteration in nomenclature has occurred traveling from pauper to service user, it is debatable finding how far attitudes towards those in demand of aid have truly changed for the better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *