Political Economy of Journalism Essay

The ‘political economic system of journalism’ is based on Marx’s review of capitalist economy. With this in head assess the followers: ‘… professionals and amateurs can organize powerful partnerships to make of import journalism’ ( Jones & A ; Salter 2002: 29 )

The term “political economy” originally denoted the survey of the conditions under which economic production was organised in the capitalist system. In Marxism. political economic system surveies the agencies of production specifically of capital. and how that manifests as economic activity ( Marx. 1867 ) . It’s simple. political economic system derives many of its analytical penetrations from the Marxist analysis of capitalist economy as a “model of production” . defined in the first case by the relationship between the “forces of production” . or the engineerings and techniques through which stuff and symbolic goods and services are produced. and the “social dealingss of production” . or the dealingss between societal agents ( such as proprietors. editors and journalists in this instance ) through which the production of such goods and services are organised. and the associated manners of distribution of the economic merchandise. This yoke of the forces and societal dealingss of production provides the base from which other societal procedures. and the overall societal construction of a historically specific manner of production. are organised.

In the political economic system of news media. capitalist economy is identified as a manner of production characterised by ‘unprecedented dynamism. continuously revolutionising its productive procedures with new engineerings and new signifiers of organizing the labor process’ ( Mosco 1995: 43 ) . Karl Marx described in Capital this relationship between the economic base and the societal construction in these footings: In the societal production of their life work forces. enter into definite dealingss that are indispensable and independent of their will. dealingss of production that will match to a definite phase of development of their stuff productive forces. The sum sum of these dealingss of production constitutes the economic construction. the existent footing on which rises a legal and political superstructure and to which correspond definite signifiers of societal consciousness. The manner of production of material life conditions the general procedure of societal. political and rational life ( Marx 1867 ) .

In his three volume work “The Information Age: Economy. Society and Culture” . the sociologist Manuel Castells has proposed that since the 1980s a new economic system has emerged that is planetary. networked and informational. While this new techno-economic model remains capitalist in signifier. it is based upon what Castells describes as an informational instead than an industrial manner of development. which he defines in these footings: In the industrial manner of development. the chief beginning of productiveness prevarications in the debuts of new energy beginnings. and in the ability to deconcentrate the usage of energy through the production and circulation procedures. In the new. informational manner of development. the beginning of productiveness prevarications in the engineering of cognition coevals. information processing. and symbol communicating … What is specific to the informational manner of development is the action of cognition upon cognition itself as the chief beginning of productiveness. I call this manner of development informational. constituted by the outgrowth of a new technological paradigm based on information engineering ( Castells 1996: 17 ) .

Castells has proposed that the rise of a web society has its beginnings in some cardinal elements derived functions of the new government of accretion. or the link between production and ingestion. identified by Castells as the “information engineering paradigm” . which is based upon the mass diffusion of information and communicating engineerings. The new economic system is networked and it is based upon information webs such as the Internet. every bit good as the networked endeavor going the dominant signifier of economic administration. at whose bosom is no longer the capitalist house. but planetary markets and concern undertakings based upon short-run strategic confederations and partnerships. For Castells. the networked endeavor is a logical corollary of electronic concern. as it is based around ‘the Internet-based. synergistic. networked connexion between manufacturers. consumers. and service providers’ ( Castells 2001: 75 ) .

It has ne’er been so easy to make information. and at the same clip it has ne’er been so hard to do a life off its pattern ; the market is bigger than of all time. but the income is the lowest in history. in comparative footings. This tendency is clearly seeable in the USA. so many times forerunner about what is traveling to go on with the remainder of the western states. The scene is rather distressing. at least in the USA. where major newspapers have seen how their diffusion has fallen from 62 million transcripts to 49 million since the Internet became mainstream with an easy entree for most of the citizens of that state 15 old ages ago. Around a 100 newspapers were forced to halt printing in paper format. During the same period. the figure of readers of digital news media has increased from zero to 75 million. The lessening in advertizements. which represents the chief income in paper news media. has reduced the net income drastically. which later has brought monolithic lay-offs as read in some of the flags of the chief European newspapers ( 1 ) .

El Pais. mention Spanish newspaper. fired more than 30 per cent of its staff after denoting a dismissal plan. The company notified 129 of its workers that they were fired via electronic mail the past 10th of November. while many of them were at their places. The ground of the redundancy was the misdirection of Juan Luis Cebrian. CEO of El Pais. harmonizing to Maruja Torres. journalist of that newspaper. in a talk at University of Barcelona: “Cebrian lost 5 billion euro chancing in casino capitalist economy. purchasing wirelesss in Miami and Latin-american Televisions that were perfectly worthless. He wanted to be a fiscal shark in Wall Street. but he really was a small pilchard who made everything incorrect. He wasted the net incomes of our work in the escapade of the best newspaper of the Spanish democracy” ( 2 ) .

In the last old ages and due to the systemic crisis experienced by this sector. the chief newspapers have faced many jobs and several of them have been forced to travel wholly their paper editions to merely On-line editions. like Publico. another Spanish newspaper. that stopped publishing its paper edition a little longer than eight months ago. because of the lessening in its gross revenues. ( 3 ) Newspapers financially survive in two ways. one is the income generated from advertisements and the other is from subscriptions. Ad is at the Centre of the argument. because. among other things. is the chief beginning of support and therefore for the endurance of traditional newspapers. As noted in The Economist in its particular study called “Bulletins from the future” ( 4 ) . the majority of the grosss had descended while at the same clip the income of On-line media grew tremendously. It is non merely that the theoretical account of concern has changed but besides the theoretical account of ingestion has changed.

The Internet has brought an unprecedented revolution in the manner we create. grip and spread information. It has demolished the old methods and has opened limitless possibilities for the amplification of a high-grade merchandise with information. Brian Winston ( 1986. 1998 ) . argues that. in contrast to claims that we are presently in the thick of an ‘information revolution’ . the historical development of engineerings such as telephone. wireless. Television. orbiters. computing machines and Internet are marked far more by continuities instead than epoch-making transmutations. Winston besides argues that. insofar as engineerings may still incorporate possible to dispute the dominant form of societal dealingss. That it’s what we are seeing in the existent acting of relationship between citizens and news media. where citizens are moving as journalists lending content that is published on traditional media.

This signifier of citizen news media includes things like publication of exposure or picture taken by amateurs who happened to be at the right topographic point at the right clip. such as the London bombardments in July 2005 or London Riots in 2011. It could besides include remark and sentiment by a blogger that subsequently appears on a mainstream media intelligence site. Most of the clip these people are non paid for their part. Citizen Journalism in this context is about ever contextualized. edited and proofread by professional journalists ( Quin & A ; Lamble 2008 ) . The website OhmyNews is one of the innovators of citizen news media. holding more than 50. 000 citizen newsmans as of March 2007. Jean Min of OhmyNews International said every narrative went through an extended showing and copyreading procedure before it was published. Although sometimes good quality web log content appears in mainstream media.

The cardinal word is quality. UK journalist Jemima Kiss concedes that the “cream” of bloggers will be experts in their field. “Blogs are frequently an extension of people’s occupation or their passions” ( 5 ) . It is logical that traditional media should seek out their accomplishments. but traditional gatekeepers have of import accomplishments that should non be underestimated. Min of OhmyNews concurs: “We believe bloggers can work better with professional aid from trained journalists. On the other manus. we besides believe professional journalists can spread out their position and range greatly with fresh input from citizen newsmans. News media as a whole can offer more diverse and rich content to readers by tapping into the wealth of Netizens’ corporate wisdom” ( Quin & A ; Lamble 2008 ) . However. citizen news media assume the function of journalists and that necessitates a argument about who is a journalist. Citizen Journalism sites win because they are easy and inexpensive to put up. Wages are frequently non an issue because people volunteer their clip.

This means these bloggers or citizen newsmans don’t want to be journalists. they merely want to be heard and respected. ( Min 2007 ) The first signifier of citizen news media is likely to go on because traditional media need quality content. and in many instances they are non paying for it. The 2nd signifier requires energy and passion to prolong itself. and a signifier of gross or concern theoretical account. Arash Amel. a senior analyst for the media analysis company Screen Digest. said “The concern theoretical account for user-generated sites has been ‘build it and sell it and allow person else worry about the concern model’ . ” News Corp admitted early in 2007 that its Fox film studio and telecasting content would be more of import than place made cartridge holders for capturing on-line picture advertisement. Screen Digest expects this market to spread out for one million millions before 2012 ( Edgecliffe-Johnson and new wave Duyn 2007 ) .

Bowman and Willis see coaction as the drive force behind the “explosion of citizen media” as passionate and motivated people produce new signifiers of media. “The democratisation of media has levelled the competitory landscape and forced dramatic alterations in the intelligence concern ( Bowman and Willis 2005: 7 ) . They reject the impression that citizen news media means the terminals of the new media companies or news media. However. in the last few old ages. the news media has been through a batch of problems because of Internet. but besides thanks to the Network and how was changed the form of consume information. a batch of possibilities has been disclosed. One of them is “crowdsourcing” . Jeff Howe ( 2006 ) was the first individual who has coined its definition. he describes crowdsourcing as a procedure that distribute problem-solving and production theoretical account.

In the authoritative usage of the term. jobs are broadcast to an unknown group of convergent thinkers in the signifier of an unfastened call for solutions. Users—also known as the crowd—submit solutions. Solutions are so owned by the entity that broadcast the job in the first place—the crowdsourcer. The subscriber of the solution is. in some instances. compensated either monetarily. with awards. or with acknowledgment. In other instances. the lone wagess may be kudos or rational satisfaction. Crowdsourcing may bring forth solutions from amateurs or voluntaries working in their trim clip. or from experts or little concerns which were unknown to the originating organisation ( Howe 2006 ) .

Reasoning comments: the planetary production of information and mass media is non built over the evidences of objectiveness and the quality of a true information. as they would do us believe. Journalism in this instance is non any different from any other capitalist industry. The production of information follows the Torahs of political economic system. that is to state. the maximization of net incomes and thanks to that fact the media proprietors trade freely with information like any other trade good on the market that is at the service of the capitalist system.


AXFORD. HUGGINS 2001. New Media and Politics. Sage Publications. London. BENDER. DAVENPORT. DRAGER. FREDLER 2009. Reporting for the Media. Oxford University Press. Oxford. CASTELLS. Manuel 1996a. The Rise of the Network Society. vol. 1 of The Information Age: Economy. Society and Culture. Blackwell. Malden. Mass. – 2001. The Internet Galaxy: Contemplations on Economy. Society and Culture. Oxford University Press. Oxford. COTTLE Simon 2003. News. Public Relations and Power. Sage Publications. London. FLEW. Terry 2002. New Media: an debut. Oxford University Press. Oxford. JONES. SALTER 2012. Digital Journalism. Sage Publications. London. MARX. Karl 1867. Capital. Verlag von Otto Meissner. Hamburg. MOSCO. Vincent 1995. The Political Economy of Communication. Sage. Calif. QUINN. Stephen ; LAMBLE. Stephen 2008. Online Newsgathering: Research and Reporting for Journalism. Focal Press. Elsevier. Burllington. SALWEN. GARRISON. DRISCOLL 2005. Online News and the Public. Lawrence WINSTON. Brian 1986. Misconstruing Media. Routledge & A ; Kegan Paul. London. Erlbaum Associates. Publishers. London. BOWMAN. WILLIS 2005. The Future is Here. But Do News Media Companies See It? . Nieman Reports. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //www. nieman. Harvard University. edu/reports/article/100558/The-Future-Is-Here-But-Do-News-Media-Companies-See-It. aspx [ cited 2012 ] EDGECLIFFE. JOHNSON & A ; VAN DUYN 2007. Murdoch is sight of Dow Jones. 21 June 2007. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //www. ft. com/cms/s/0/cde8a968-2016-11dc-9eb1 000b5df10621. hypertext markup language # axzz2CPrMqwcR [ cited 2012 ] HOWE. Jeff 2006. The Rise of Crowdsourcing. Wired Magazine. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //www. wired. com/wired/archive/14. 06/crowds. hypertext markup language MIN. Jean 2007. Interview. 29 May 2007. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //laazotea. blogspot. co. uk/2007/05/entrevista-jean-k-mings-ohmynews. hypertext markup language [ cited 2012 ] CARLING. John. El momento important. El Pais. 10 May 2009. Available from: hypertext transfer protocol: //elpais. com/diario/2009/05/10/domingo/1241927553_850215. hypertext markup language [ cited 2012 ] TORRES. Maruja. Preguntes que ELs periodistes nuts hauriem de fer cada

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *